Ukulele vs Guitar: A 5 minute explainer

There comes a time in every guitarist's journey when they purchase a ukulele - and then they realize the reality vs expectation is very different.

The ukulele and the guitar do share a lot of commonalities. They're both part of the lute family and their similar anatomy means that the rhythm techniques, from strumming to fingerpicking, as well as general playing techniques, like bends, hammer-ons, and chording, will translate well from one to the other.

However, the ukulele is not a miniaturized guitar or a guitarist's travel companion. For that use case there are better mini guitar options.‍

This guide is mainly for guitarists picking up a ukulele for the first time - it's much rarer that someone picks up the ukulele and then transitions to guitar but either way there should be some nuggets of wisdom written below.

Similarities Between Ukulele and Guitar

Construction.

‍Both the ukulele and the acoustic guitar comprise of a hollow body that resonates sound, a neck with frets to alter pitch, and a headstock where the tuning pegs are found.
‍
Both instruments can be found with either nylon or steel strings, depending on the genre or preference of the player. Classical guitars and many ukuleles, in particular, utilize nylon strings for a warm, mellow sound. Typically jumping from steel and woven strings to nylon strings is not that big of a departure.

Playability.

In terms of playability, the techniques used to play both instruments overlap as mentioned before. Fretting, fingerpicking, and strumming patterns can be interchanged between the two.

The Big Difference Between Ukuleles & Guitars

The biggest differences between a guitar and ukulele from an anatomy perspectives are both the smaller size and the lesser number of strings. Guitars typically have six strings while ukuleles always come with four strings.

The biggest difference between a guitar and ukulele from a playability and technique perspective is that the tuning and string pitch is significantly different.

Standard tuning for a ukulele (G-C-E-A) is very different than either the bottom four strings of a guitar (D-G-B-E) and the top four strings (E-A-D-G).

Because of this, especially the inclusion of a C-note in standard tuning, means that the pattern of shapes we're familiar with for chords and scales on the guitar require a new way of thinking on the ukulele. That doesn't mean you can't play a major pentatonic scale on a ukulele but simply that the fingering pattern of it at various points on the neck is very different.

Additionally, the G string of a ukulele is tuned to the higher octave. This tends to throw guitarists off because our ears are used to going from low to high notes (or vice versa) without any linear interruption. The high G is a bit of an oddity on the ukulele.

All this means that adjusting to the smaller ukulele body is much easier than translating your memorization of chord and scale shapes from one instrument to the other.

Size and Construction Differences

TThe most obvious difference between a guitar and a ukulele is the difference in size. The guitar is approximately twice as large as a ukulele in both overall length as well as the length of their necks.

Ukuleles do come in various sizes, with the most common types being soprano, concert, tenor, and baritone ukuleles. The size and scale length vary depending on the type of ukulele:

• Soprano ukulele: The smallest type, measuring around 21 inches in length with a scale length of 13 inches.
• Concert ukulele: Slightly larger than the soprano, measuring around 23 inches in length and a scale length of 15 inches.
• Tenor ukulele: More substantial, measuring around 26 inches in length and a scale length of 17 inches.
• Baritone ukulele: The largest type, measuring around 30 inches in length and a scale length of 19 inches.

On the other hand, guitars come in several body shapes and sizes as well. The most common type is the dreadnought, which has a larger body size of about 40 inches in length with a scale length of about 25 inches. However, you can also find acoustic guitars in a much smaller parlor design or 3/4 travel length sizes as well.

In terms of construction, both guitar and ukulele share some similarities, such as using wooden materials for the body and employing steel or nylon strings.

The smaller size of a ukulele as well as the gentler nylon strings makes them great for kids - both of my kids have had a ukulele since they were 2 years old! However, a ukulele isn't what I'd consider a "beginner" guitar. In fact, you may want to take a look at the Loog three string guitar for kids since their tuning and string gauge are more comparable to a real guitar.

Sound and Tone

When comparing the sound and tone of a ukulele and a guitar, there are notable differences due to their unique construction and tuning. The ukulele, typically associated with Hawaiian island vibes, has a softer more delicate sound. On the other hand, the guitar has a broader range and is obviously used across a number of musical genres.

The materials used in making the two instruments contribute to their distinct "timbres". Ukuleles are generally made from lighter woods, such as mahogany or koa, producing a brighter and more resonant tone. Guitars commonly utilize heavier woods like rosewood or maple, which contribute to a warmer and richer sound. This difference in construction also affects the volume, with guitars generally being louder than ukuleles.

Guitars, in contrast, offer two primary types: acoustic and electric. Acoustic guitars often come with steel strings that create a bright and crisp sound ideal for genres like rock, pop, and folk. Nylon-stringed classical guitars offer a warmer tone, suitable for classical and flamenco music. Electric guitars use magnetic pickups and amplifiers to shape their tone, enabling versatility for styles such as jazz, blues, and rock.

There's no right or wrong here - the choice between a ukulele and a guitar is just personal preference and even more likely based on which mood you're in or what desired sound you're going for with a particular song.

Learning Ukulele vs Guitar

The learning curve of a ukulele and guitar is hard to compare although most would say that the ukulele is easier to pick up with its lesser number of strings as well narrow range of musical genres covered.

The first consideration is comfort and ease of use for beginners. Generally, the ukulele is considered a more beginner-friendly instrument due to its smaller size and fewer frets. This makes it more comfortable and easier to hold and manage, especially for those with smaller fingers.

In terms of chord shapes, the ukulele's four strings require simpler chords than the guitar's six strings. Many beginners find one- and two-finger chords on the ukulele easier to play, allowing them to pick up basic techniques more quickly. This results in a simpler learning curve, as well as less finger strain compared to guitar playing.

Guitar, on the other hand, has a wider range of techniques, chords, and styles to learn. While this can be more challenging for beginners, it also offers greater versatility once these skills are mastered. The larger number of frets and strings allow for more complex chord shapes and a broader range of notes, which can be both intriguing and daunting for new players.

Popular Music and Versatility

The guitar and ukulele are both popular musical instruments that can be found in a variety of genres, each offering its own unique advantages. When it comes to popular music, the guitar has been a staple in many genres such as rock, pop, jazz, and blues. On the other hand, the ukulele has seen a surge in popularity in recent years, featuring in various indie, folk, and pop songs.

In terms of versatility, the guitar offers a wider range of musical options than the ukulele. With six strings and a larger range of notes, the guitar is capable of producing a broad array of sounds and styles. Additionally, the guitar can be played both acoustically and electrically, allowing for even greater musical possibilities.

On the other hand, the ukulele is a more portable and lightweight instrument, typically constructed with four strings and often made from wood or plastic. This smaller construction contributes to the ukulele's unique, bright sound that has captured the hearts of many musicians and listeners alike. While the instrument may be limited in its musical scope compared to the guitar, it still offers a charming and captivating sound that suits a variety of genres.

In terms of amplification, both the guitar and the ukulele have options to enhance their sound. Electric guitars can be connected to amplifiers and effects pedals to create a wide array of sounds, while acoustic guitars can be equipped with pickups or microphones for amplification. Similarly, the ukulele can also be amplified using pickups or microphones, which can help bring out its distinctive tone in live performances or studio recordings.

Price and Value

Ukuleles generally have a lower price point than guitars, making them an attractive option for beginners or those on a budget. The cost of a decent ukulele can start from $50, while an acceptable beginner guitar may range from $100 to $200. Keep in mind that the best ukulele or guitar for someone depends on personal preferences and playing style.

Ukuleles:

• Lower price point
• Good option for beginners
• Prices starting at $50

Guitars:

• Higher price point
• Beginner options range from $100-$200

The feel of the instrument is also an important consideration. Ukuleles are generally easier to learn due to their smaller size and fewer strings. The nylon strings found on most ukuleles are also gentler on the fingertips than the steel strings on guitars, leading to greater comfort for new players.

To ensure a balance between price and value, it is essential to consider the quality of the instrument and the player's dedication. A high-quality ukulele or guitar might be a better long-term investment for someone committed to mastering the instrument, but a more affordable option is suitable for those exploring their interests. Remember, the best ukulele or guitar is one that meets your specific needs and preferences without breaking your budget.

Making the Choice: Ukulele vs Guitar

There's really no right or wrong and in fact most of us choose both. I have one electric, one acoustic, and one ukulele right next to my bed so that I can pick up whichever one I'm in the mood for at any time.

Some factors to consider when choosing between the ukulele and the guitar are:

• Personal preference: Which sound do you enjoy more? Listen to both instruments being played and identify the one that resonates with you.
• Dedication: Are you willing to invest the time and effort to master the chosen instrument? A guitar might require more dedication due to its complexity, while the ukulele can offer quicker results for beginners.
• Physical comfort: Is the size and weight of the instrument comfortable for you? Ukuleles are lighter and smaller, making them easier to handle, whereas guitars can be more challenging, especially for those with smaller hands or limited mobility.
• Budget: How much are you willing to spend on your instrument? Generally, ukuleles are more affordable than guitars; however, the price range can vary for both, based on quality and brand.

‍

‍

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between a ukulele and a guitar?

A ukulele is smaller and typically has four nylon or gut strings, while a guitar is larger and usually has six steel or nylon strings. The tuning for ukuleles is G-C-E-A, whereas guitars have a standard tuning of E-A-D-G-B-E. The ukulele's smaller size and different tuning give it a distinct sound compared to guitars.

Is it easier to learn to play the ukulele or the guitar?

Many beginners find the ukulele easier to learn due to its smaller size, which makes it more comfortable to hold and play. The nylon strings are also gentler on the fingers, and with fewer strings, chord shapes tend to be simpler. However, individual experiences may vary, and personal preference plays a significant role.

Why do people play the ukulele instead of the guitar?

Some musicians prefer the ukulele because of its lighter, more portable nature and distinct sound. Ukuleles also have a more casual and laid-back reputation, which can be appealing to those who enjoy playing in informal settings. Additionally, ukuleles tend to be more affordable than guitars.

What are the advantages of playing a ukulele?

Playing a ukulele has several advantages, such as its portability, affordability, and beginner-friendly nature. The unique sound of the ukulele offers a refreshing change from the guitar, especially for listeners. It also brings a certain charm to certain music styles like traditional Hawaiian songs and contemporary indie music.

What are the disadvantages of ukulele?

The ukulele, while a charming and portable instrument, does have some disadvantages compared to a regular guitar. First, its smaller size and fewer strings limit its range and versatility and the difference in the standard ukulele tuning, GCEA, can be a challenge for guitarists accustomed to the standard EADGBE tuning, making it difficult to transfer skills between the two instruments. All that said, the ukulele is a wonderful stringed instrument and guitarists would have a blast as ukulele players.

What are the typical sizes of ukuleles compared to guitars?

Ukuleles come in four primary sizes: soprano, concert, tenor, and baritone. Soprano is the smallest, with a length of around 20-21 inches, followed by concert (23-24 inches), tenor (26-27 inches), and baritone (29-30 inches). Guitars are generally larger, with classical guitars measuring around 38-39 inches and acoustic guitars at 40-42 inches.

How does the sound of a ukulele differ from that of a guitar?

The sound of a ukulele is generally characterized by a brighter, lighter, and more carefree tone compared to guitars. Due to its smaller size and different tuning, the ukulele offers a unique timbre that complements various genres, from traditional Hawaiian music to modern pop and indie styles.

‍