Can You Play Guitar with Long Nails? There's a catch.

There are many things you need to focus on in order to play guitar - who would've thought that the length of your fingernails would be one of them?

I recently became obsessed with learning Sultans of Swing by Dire Straits and trying to emulate Mark Knopfler's fingers only approach to playing the guitar. I became pretty good but got to a point where it was clear that I needed to grow out my fingernails to really perfect his style. My wife and my kids have started to ask me a lot of questions.

Yes, you can play guitar with long nails but only if they're on your strumming hand and not on your fretting hand. This means that guitarists will often have slightly longer nails on their dominant hand so that they can fingerpick with ease while moving swiftly up and down the guitar neck and across the fretboard without damaging it.

At the same time very long nails, acrylic nails, or fake nails on either hand is not a good idea, even if just on the dominant strumming hand, as these long nails will interfere with your ability to accurately pluck individual guitar strings while finger picking.

Simply put, the most common choice for guitarists is naturally rounded fingernails on both hands. For those who like to finger pick, they will have slightly longer and sometimes pointed fingernails on their picking hand.

This presents some really tough choices especially for female guitarists who now represent over 50% of amateur guitarists. So, for all of our readers, let's dive in deeper.

Understanding the Role of Fingernails in Guitar Playing

Fingernails play an essential role in guitar playing, and their length can significantly affect the sound and technique of a player. While some guitarists prefer to keep their nails short, others opt to grow them long on their plucking hand and use them to enhance their playing.

Long fingernails on the dominant hand increases volume and sustain, improves tone, and enhances your fingerpicking ability. However, they can pose challenges, such as difficulty in fretting and strumming, and the risk of breaking or splitting the nails.

When playing the guitar, the nails act as a natural extension of the fingers but they also serve as individually controlled picks. The length of the nails can affect the angle and pressure of the fingers on the strings, which can impact the tone and volume of the sound produced.

Additionally, long nails can provide a player with more control over their fingerpicking technique, as they can use each individual nail to pluck and produce a sharper and more defined sound. However, it is essential to note that some guitarists prefer to use their fingertips instead of their nails for fingerpicking, and it ultimately comes down to personal preference and playing style.

In conclusion, the length of fingernails can significantly impact guitar playing, and it is up to each player to decide whether they prefer to keep their nails short or grow them long. While there are advantages and challenges to both approaches, the most important thing is to find a playing style that is comfortable and suits the individual's needs and preferences.

Challenges of Playing Guitar with Long Fingernails

Playing guitar with long fingernails can be a challenge. While some people may find it comfortable and easy to play the guitar with long nails, others may find it difficult. Here are some of the challenges that come with playing guitar with long fingernails:

1. Difficulty in holding the strings

Extremely long nails can make it difficult to hold the strings properly, especially when playing chords. The nails can get in the way and make it hard to press down on the strings, causing the sound to be muted or not come out at all. The feeling of nails on a fretboard drives me insane!

2. Difficulty in fingerpicking

Fingerpicking can be a challenge when playing guitar with long fingernails but it's a skill worth picking up - especially for classical guitar. Here's a great video from Merce Font to help sharpen (heh) your right-hand technique.

3. Risk of breaking nails

Long fingernails are more prone to breaking, which can be a problem for guitar players. Broken nails can cause pain and make it difficult to play the guitar properly. It's important to keep the nails trimmed and filed to avoid this problem.

Techniques for Playing Guitar with Long Fingernails

Long fingernails can make it challenging to play the guitar, but it is not impossible. With the right techniques, guitar players can still play their favorite songs and create beautiful music. In this section, we will discuss two techniques for playing guitar with long fingernails: classical guitar techniques and fingerpicking techniques.

Classical Guitar Techniques

Classical guitarists have long nails on their right hand to pluck the strings. However, they do not use their left hand nails to fret the notes. Instead, they use the tips of their fingers. This technique allows them to have more control over the strings, produce a clear sound, and avoid accidental muting of the strings.

To play classical guitar with long fingernails, it is recommended to keep the nails on the right hand long and to keep natural nails regularly trimmed on the left hand. It is also important to keep the nails clean and well-maintained to avoid any unwanted noises or scratches on the guitar.

Fingerpicking Techniques

Fingerpicking is a popular technique that involves using the fingers to pluck the strings instead of a pick. Guitarists with long fingernails can still use this technique by adjusting their hand position and fingerpicking style.

One way to play fingerstyle guitar with long nails is to use the side of the fingers instead of the tips. This technique allows the player to have more control over the strings and avoid any unwanted noises or scratches.

Another technique is to use fingerpicks. Fingerpicks are small plastic or metal picks that attach to the fingertips. They allow the player to have more control over the strings and produce a crisper sound. However, it may take some time to get used to playing with fingerpicks.

In conclusion, playing guitar with long fingernails requires some adjustments in technique and maintenance. Classical guitarists can keep their right hand nails long and trim the nails on their left hand. Fingerstyle guitarists can use the side of their fingers or fingerpicks to play. With practice and patience, guitar players with long fingernails can still enjoy playing their favorite songs.

Maintaining Long Fingernails for Guitar Playing

Nail Care Tips

Maintaining long fingernails for guitar playing requires a certain level of care and attention. Here are some tips to help keep your nails healthy and strong:

• Keep your nails clean and dry to prevent fungal infections.
• Use a nail file to shape your nails, avoiding sharp edges that can catch on strings.
• Apply a strengthening treatment to your nails to help prevent breakage.
• Avoid using harsh chemicals or detergents that can weaken nails.
• Moisturize your nails and cuticles regularly to prevent dryness and cracking.

Pros and Cons of Playing Guitar with Long Fingernails

Playing guitar with long fingernails can be a controversial topic among guitar players. Some believe that long fingernails can enhance the sound and technique, while others argue that it's a hindrance. Here are some pros and cons of playing guitar with long fingernails:

Pros:

• Long fingernails can help produce a fuller and richer sound, especially when playing fingerstyle or classical guitar.
• They can provide a natural pick, allowing for more control and precision in playing.
• Long fingernails can also protect the fingertips from calluses and blisters, making it easier to play for longer periods of time.

Cons:

• Long fingernails can make it difficult to press down on the strings, leading to buzzing or muted notes.
• They can also get in the way when playing certain techniques, such as tapping or bending.
• Maintaining long fingernails requires extra care and attention, including regular filing and avoiding activities that can cause them to break or chip.

Overall, whether or not to play guitar with long fingernails is a personal preference that depends on the individual's playing style and technique. While there are some advantages to having long fingernails, there are also some drawbacks that may make it more challenging to play certain songs or techniques.

Conclusion

In conclusion, playing guitar with long fingernails is possible, but it requires some adjustments and compromises.

Players with long fingernails should keep in mind that they may need to modify their technique to avoid unwanted noise or buzzing. They may also need to adjust their hand position or angle to avoid hitting the strings with their nails unintentionally.

On the other hand, players with long fingernails may find some advantages, such as a brighter tone, a smoother slide, or a unique sound. They may also enjoy the aesthetic appeal of their nails and use them as a part of their style and expression.

Ultimately, the decision to play guitar with long fingernails is a personal one, and it depends on various factors, such as the player's preference, goals, genre, and skill level.

Here are some key points to consider when playing guitar with long fingernails:

• Long fingernails can produce a brighter tone and a smoother slide, but they can also cause unwanted noise and buzzing.
• Players with long fingernails may need to adjust their technique and hand position to avoid hitting the strings with their nails unintentionally.
• Players with long fingernails may enjoy the aesthetic appeal of their nails and use them as a part of their style and expression.
• The decision to play guitar with long fingernails is a personal one, and it depends on various factors, such as the player's preference, goals, genre, and skill level.

Overall, playing guitar with long fingernails is not a definitive yes or no answer, but rather a matter of experimentation, adaptation, and creativity. With the right approach and mindset, players with long fingernails can achieve their musical goals and express themselves through their instrument.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I play guitar without using a pick?

There are several techniques for playing guitar without a pick. One technique is to use your fingers to pluck the strings. Another technique is to use your thumb to strum the strings. You can also use a combination of both techniques to create different sounds.

What are some techniques for playing guitar with longer nails?

If you have longer nails, you can use them to pluck the strings. This technique is called fingerstyle. You can also use your nails to create a percussive sound by tapping on the strings. Another technique is to angle your fingers so that your nails don't get in the way of the strings.

What are the best nail shapes for guitar playing?

The best nail shape for guitar playing is a square shape. This allows for maximum contact with the strings and produces a clear sound. However, some guitar players prefer a rounded shape for a softer sound.

Are there any famous guitar players who play with long nails?

Yes, there are many famous guitar players who play with long nails. Some examples include Mark Knopfler, Lindsey Buckingham, and Andrés Segovia.

Can short-fingered people play guitar?

Yes, short-fingered people can play guitar. There are techniques that can help compensate for shorter fingers, such as using a capo or playing closer to the frets.

Do I need to trim my nails to play guitar?

No, you don't necessarily need to trim your nails to play guitar. However, shorter nails may make it easier to play certain techniques, such as barre chords. Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference and what works best for you.

‍